CONSUMER ADVISORY

   February 2010                                             By Attorney General Tom Miller

 

 

It’s tax season, and tax preparers may invite you to get a “Refund Anticipation Loan” or “RAL” – a loan borrowed against your expected tax refund.  Such a loan may come a few days faster than a refund – but you pay extremely high fees to borrow your own money.

 

            A  “Refund Anticipation Loan” is a very short-term LOAN, arranged by a tax preparer and secured by your expected tax refund.  You pay finance charges and tax-preparation fees.  The loan is repaid when the IRS sends your full refund to the lending bank.

 

            Refund anticipation loans are EXPENSIVE.  According to a 2009 report by the Consumer Federation of America and the National Consumer Law Center, consumers paid over $833 million in loan fees on RALs in 2007.  The average loan costs include a $34 to $130 loan fee and administrative or application fees that can range from $25 to hundreds of dollars.  With all costs and fees, the APR (annual percentage rate) for RALs varies from 50% to 1300%!  That’s a bad bargain for an “advance” of just a few days.

 

            Refund anticipation loans encourage FRAUD.  A 2008 IRS study found that RAL filings were 27% to 36% more likely to be non-compliant than were returns without a loan.

 

 

·          “How much will I pay for the loan?”  The typical RAL finance charge for a $3,000 refund is $62-$110, or a 77%-140% APR.  Those costs can double or triple with additional fees for tax preparation, electronic filing, or check-cashing.

 

·          “What does the fee buy me?”  An RAL gets your refund to you in 1-4 days, compared to just 7-10 days for an ordinary electronic refund deposit to your bank.

           

            Beware also of “pay stub RALs”.  Pay stub RALs are based on a taxpayer’s estimated tax refund as indicated on his or her  latest pay stub.   They are offered before a taxpayer receives a W-2 form.  The estimated amount, however, may be incorrect and the taxpayer will have to pay the full amount, whether or not the refund is large enough to cover all costs and fees.  Pay stub RALs charge high fees just like other RALs.

           

            IRS data shows that nearly one in fifteen taxpayers  took out an RAL in 2007.  Two-thirds of these were low-income workers or Earned Income Tax Credit recipients (EITC) who can receive free tax assistance. In February, a list of “Volunteer Income Tax Assistance” and “Tax Counseling for the Elderly” sites in Iowa will be available at .  For more information, contact the Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division.  Call 515-281-5926, or 888-777-4590 toll-free.

 

Consumer Protection Division ! Hoover Bldg. ! Des Moines, IA 50319 ! 515/281-5926 ! 888/777-4590